To this affront, I say, six times:
I ordered a new copy.
I loved this book when I was growing up (even the space ship button). Witches were VERY important in the pretend world I created, either with friends, on paper, or in my imagination. Witches from literature always hold spots dear to my heart. The White Witch (I know she's evil, but she's so BEAUTIFUL). Samantha Stevens (although who am I kidding, it was ALWAYS Endora. Always.). Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle, Mary Poppins, and even Cruella De Vil all were witch-adjacent. Later, Diana Wynne Jones captured my heart (Witch Week was first); and of course, much later there was Harry Potter.
I don't ever remember playing or pretending this book with my friends, probably because they never read it. But certainly, my ideas of what constitutes a good fantasy novel in part comes from The Witch's Buttons. The idea that witches live among us, practicing magic in an urban or "muggle" setting, is still a trope I love. Here, the setting is Brooklyn, although as a child, it never even occurred to me that Brooklyn was part of New York City or urban; these girls don't seem very urban to me. Reading it now, as an adult, I was realized where they actually lived. Probably some hipster Brooklynites are dressing the way she is on the cover even now, and collecting (or making their own) buttons.
The button seller behind the counter is Jewish! All I ever noticed before was how much witch Betsy resembled a very young Agnes Moorhead.
I still love the illustration of the little black kitten running across the gutter at the bottom:
Ruth Chew never gives ages for Sandy or her new friend Janet, but when I was reading the book for the first time, I'm sure I thought Janet and Sandy were the same age as me (third or fourth grade). I , too, had a baby sister I had to occasionally babysit as well!
The book was published in 1974, so I can't be the baby in the book (I was four) but my brother could have been that baby!
Love the bell bottom pant suit on the cover. Very, very much.
In my original review on Goodreads, I commented that "I hoped Ruth Chew would make a come back." Guess what - she has! They are republishing her books with new covers. No more bell bottoms (too bad) but still great books!
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
Definitely an early chapter book straight out of nostalgia for me (we didn't call them chapter backs in my school library in the 1970s; we just called them "books"). I think this book holds up remarkably well 40 years or so after being published. Other than the groovy, far out bell bottom pants suit on the cover, the magical adventures of Sandy and Janet are still quite fun. Perhaps not as rollicking as J.K. Rowling, but Ruth Chew weaves a pretty tight and exciting story. Truly urban fantasy; the book takes place in Brooklyn (although I don't think many Brooklynites of today would recognize it as such). I've had a love affair with witches of fiction for most of my reading life, which most likely germinating in books like this, read and re-read over and over in third, fourth and fifth grade.